Categories

AOAV: all our reportsMilitarism examinedCivilian Casualties from British Military

D-Day anniversary: remembering the civilian cost amidst the joy of liberation

As the world commemorates the 80th anniversary of D-Day, a report by John Leicester of the Associated Press (AP) and insights from Gary Lee Kraut’s France Revisited article illuminate the often overlooked civilian toll of the historic invasion. While D-Day is celebrated for its crucial role in liberating Nazi-occupied Europe, the operation also resulted in significant civilian casualties in Normandy, where around 20,000 French residents lost their lives.

In the small town of Carentan, memories of the invasion remain vivid for Yves Marchais, who was just six years old in 1944. He recalls the kindness of American soldiers who handed out oranges—a rare treat in war-torn, Nazi-occupied France. These moments of generosity are contrasted with the traumatic experiences of relentless bombings that turned the skies red and buried countless victims under rubble. The young Marchais counted 35 oranges in his hands, thrilled at the sight of fruit he had never seen before.

The Normandy invasion saw Allied forces battling through heavily fortified German defenses, encountering fierce resistance that resulted in high casualties on both sides. The Allied bombing campaigns, aimed at disrupting German reinforcements and strongholds, left many Norman towns in ruins. Cities such as Caen, Rouen, and Le Havre were heavily bombed, resulting in significant civilian casualties and widespread destruction.

Marchais recalls how his family’s house in Carentan shook during the bombardments that sounded “like thunder.” He also vividly remembers his mother’s resilience, gulping down a bottle of strong Normandy cider in their basement shelter, declaring, “That’s another one that the Germans won’t drink!” These personal anecdotes reflect the complex emotions and memories of those who lived through the invasion.

Operation Overlord: Three soldiers of the 23rd Field Ambulance place flowers on civilian graves. (Photo by Galerie Bilderwelt/Getty Images)

French President Emmanuel Macron, during a commemoration in Saint-Lo, highlighted the sacrifices made by civilians, referring to the town as “a necessary target” to halt German advances. The town, razed on June 6 and 7, 1944, lost 352 residents to the bombings. The immense suffering endured by civilians in towns like Saint-Lo earned it the somber title of “The Capital of the Ruins,” as described by playwright Samuel Beckett, who witnessed the aftermath while working with the Irish Red Cross.

The Allied bombing was aimed at stopping Hitler from sending reinforcements and at prying his troops out of the “Atlantic Wall” of coastal defenses and other strongpoints that German occupation forces had built with forced labor. However, the civilian toll was severe, with towns such as Argentan, Aunay-sur-Odon, Condé-sur-Noireau, Coutances, Falaise, Flers, Lisieux, Vimoutiers, and Vire suffering significant destruction and loss of life. Leaflets scattered by Allied planes urged civilians to “LEAVE IMMEDIATELY! YOU DON’T HAVE A MINUTE TO LOSE!” but often missed their targets, leaving many civilians in peril.

Some Normans were furious. Writing before being liberated, a woman in the bombarded port city of Cherbourg described Allied pilots as “bandits and assassins” in a June 4, 1944, letter to her husband, who was being held prisoner in Germany. “My dear Henri, it’s shameful to massacre the civilian population as the supposed Allies are doing,” reads the letter, published in a 1994 study of civilian victims in Normandy’s Manche region by historians Michel Boivin and Bernard Garnier. “We are in danger everywhere.”

Historians like Françoise Passera of the University of Caen emphasize that the stories of civilian victims have long been overshadowed by the military achievements of the Allies. “Civilian victims were swept under the carpet somewhat to not offend the Americans and British,” Passera notes. This sentiment was echoed until recently, with former French President François Hollande being the first to nationally honor Normandy’s civilian dead in 2014. Until then, because France had been bombed by its liberators, “this was not a subject that could be raised very easily by French authorities,” Passera said.

One poignant story from Saint-Lo involves Marguerite Lecarpentier, who was six years old at the time of the bombings. Her older brother, Henri, was killed while trying to rescue a teenage girl from the rubble. The family identified Henri’s body by his new shoes. Despite the trauma, Lecarpentier speaks without rancor of the Allied bombing, acknowledging it as “the price to pay” for liberation. “When one thinks that they landed on June 6 and that Saint-Lo was only liberated on July 18 and they lost enormous numbers of soldiers,” she said.

The Museum of the Civilian in Falaise, which Gary Lee Kraut describes in his France Revisited article, offers a comprehensive look at the civilian experience during the Normandy invasion. The museum presents poignant displays and personal stories that highlight the resilience and suffering of those who lived through the bombings. By focusing on the civilian perspective, the museum provides a more complete understanding of the impact of D-Day on Normandy.

Dr. Iain Overton, Executive Director of Action on Armed Violence (AOAV), underscores the importance of recognizing the civilian impact of military operations. “The civilian cost of conflict is often overshadowed by military valor. It is essential to acknowledge and honor the innocent lives lost in the crossfire of liberation efforts,” he says.

As highlighted in Leicester’s AP report and Kraut’s France Revisited article, reflecting on the events of D-Day requires acknowledging the full spectrum of its impact. The liberation of France came at a great cost, not only to the soldiers who bravely fought but also to the civilians who endured unimaginable horrors. Their stories are a crucial part of the historical tapestry, reminding us of the profound and often tragic consequences of war. The sacrifices of these civilians must be remembered alongside the heroism of the Allied troops, ensuring a holistic understanding of the costs of war and the price of freedom.