Categories

Explosive violence by the Israeli Defense ForcesAOAV: all our reportsExplosive violence in GazaArms exports examined

Op-ed: what are the limits, in any, to self-defence by Israel?

The deployment of the U.S. Thaad anti-missile system to Israel, following Iran’s missile attacks, is presented as a necessary defensive measure. Framed in the language of self-defence, it reinforces a familiar narrative: that Israel, under persistent threat from hostile forces like Iran, has every right to defend itself. But what this framing obscures is a far more complex and troubling reality—one where the notion of self-defence is being stretched to legitimise actions that far exceed proportionality and accountability.

Self-defence is, undoubtedly, a right enshrined in international law. Article 51 of the UN Charter makes it clear that any state facing an armed attack has the right to defend itself. The U.S. deployment of Thaad missiles, with their ability to intercept ballistic threats, underscores this principle. But when Keir Starmer and Joe Biden emphasise Israel’s right to self-defence without critically addressing the broader context of violence in Gaza and the West Bank, they risk legitimising all of Israel’s military actions, no matter how disproportionate or destructive they may be.

The presence of Thaad missiles shifts the narrative towards Iran’s aggression, implying that the greatest threat in the region stems from Iranian missiles. Yet this focus distracts from the undeniable and devastating impact of Israel’s ongoing military campaign in Gaza. Over the past year, according to Oxfam, more women and children have been killed in Gaza by Israeli forces than in any recent conflict over the last two decades. More than 6,000 women and 11,000 children lost their lives, and AOAV’s data shows that explosive weapons hit civilian infrastructure in Gaza every three hours on average. These numbers should not be seen as incidental to a war of self-defence; they are a direct result of it.

The U.S. and UK governments’ unconditional support of Israel’s defensive measures, symbolised by the deployment of Thaad, frames the conflict in a narrow lens that casts Israel solely and without critique as the victim of aggression. This narrative leaves little room for questioning the legitimacy of Israel’s actions in Gaza or Lebanon, where the overwhelming majority of casualties are civilians. While Biden and Starmer speak of proportionality, the reality on the ground tells a different story. AOAV has documented that homes in Gaza are struck every four hours, and schools and hospitals every four days. The civilian death toll has reached unprecedented levels, yet this is all too often ignored in discussions of Israel’s right to self-defence.

The deployment of Thaad missiles feeds into a broader narrative that justifies military action under the guise of security, while turning a blind eye to the consequences of that action on civilians. The disproportionate response—where civilian infrastructure is bombed into ruin—suggests that Israel’s interpretation of self-defence is often less about defending its people and more about sustaining an occupation through overwhelming force.

Oxfam’s report highlights the devastating impact on women and children in Gaza, with more than 25,000 children having lost a parent or becoming orphans in the past year. These figures represent a human cost that cannot be dismissed as collateral damage in the name of security.

What is particularly dangerous about this framing is that it normalizes an endless cycle of violence. Israel’s actions are justified as necessary, defensive measures against a rogue state in Iran, while the devastation in Gaza is relegated to the background. The Thaad missile system becomes a symbol of this skewed narrative, where the right to self-defence is invoked to obscure the realities of occupation, siege, and disproportionate use of force.

There is a broader issue at play here, one that goes beyond the deployment of Thaad or the rhetoric of self-defence. The international community, by offering Israel advanced weaponry and political cover, is complicit in perpetuating a narrative that absolves Israel of accountability. By focusing solely on Israel’s right to defend itself against Iran, global leaders like Biden and Starmer ignore the fact that Israeli actions in Gaza are not only violating International Humanitarian Law (IHL) but are also contributing to a humanitarian catastrophe.

AOAV’s work in tracking the impact of explosive weapons on civilians underscores the urgent need for accountability. The destruction of Gaza’s infrastructure, the displacement of civilians, and the sheer scale of the casualties demand that we question the legitimacy of invoking self-defence as a blanket justification for military actions. The principle of proportionality, central to IHL, must be applied rigorously, not only to Iran’s missile attacks on Israel but also to Israel’s airstrikes on Gaza.

Any less risks diluting the very principles of self-defence and, in so doing, the very bedrock of restraint in war.