Overview
This report, ‘Responding to gun massacres: a discourse analysis of how political and media narratives shape health and justice responses’, examines how media and political narratives frame mass shootings, focusing on public health, criminal justice, and societal responses in three contexts: Dunblane, Las Vegas, and Port Arthur.
In the UK, the Dunblane massacre in 1996, where 16 children and a teacher were killed, led to significant gun control reforms. Left-leaning media such as The Guardian framed the tragedy as a public health crisis, emphasising the mental and physical trauma of victims and the community while advocating for stricter firearm regulations. In contrast, right-leaning outlets like The Telegraph highlighted criminal justice aspects, blaming cultural violence and police inaction, while largely downplaying the role of gun control. The subsequent legislative response, spearheaded by Labour politicians and bolstered by public campaigns like the Snowdrop petition, prioritised public safety, culminating in a near-total handgun ban.
In the United States, the 2017 Las Vegas shooting, the deadliest in modern U.S. history, exposed sharp divides in media and political rhetoric. Left-leaning outlets like The New York Times framed the event as a public health emergency, focusing on the overwhelming strain on hospitals and the psychological toll on survivors and responders. They strongly advocated for legislative reforms, including banning bump stocks and introducing stricter firearm controls. In stark contrast, Fox News downplayed the public health impact, framing the shooting as a criminal justice issue and attributing the attack to individual mental instability. Republican politicians echoed this approach, offering condolences and emphasising law enforcement without addressing systemic gun violence, while Democrats called for recognizing gun violence as a public health epidemic requiring comprehensive legislative action.
Australia’s response to the 1996 Port Arthur massacre was swift and transformative, with bipartisan support for the National Firearms Agreement (NFA) under conservative Prime Minister John Howard. Media coverage across ideological lines converged in framing the shooting as a public health crisis. The Sydney Morning Herald explicitly addressed the mental and physical trauma of survivors, healthcare workers, and the wider community, linking gun violence to insufficient mental healthcare and societal violence. The Australian Financial Review, while less explicit, focused on community safety and the societal costs of lax gun laws. Politicians emphasised public well-being and framed gun control as a preventive measure, balancing the discourse by acknowledging mental health and cultural issues as contributing factors without using them to preclude regulatory reform.
The analysis highlights cultural differences in framing gun violence. UK and Australian left-leaning media consistently emphasise public health consequences and societal trauma, advocating for stricter regulations. In the U.S., left-leaning outlets similarly focus on public health but face greater opposition from right-leaning media, which frame gun violence through individual criminality and mental health narratives while resisting regulatory reforms. Australian political and media unity in framing gun violence as a public health issue contrasts sharply with polarised approaches in the UK and the U.S., facilitating swift and comprehensive legislative action in response to Port Arthur. This study underscores the power of public health framing in shaping policy and public discourse on gun violence.
Methodology
This study employs qualitative discourse analysis to examine media reporting, political statements, and legislative debates following mass shootings in the UK, US, and Australia. Sources were selected from prominent national newspapers representing both left- and right-leaning perspectives, including The Guardian, The Telegraph, The New York Times, Fox News, The Sydney Morning Herald, and The Australian Financial Review. Parliamentary debates, policy documents, and public statements were also analysed to identify dominant narratives. Key themes such as public health, criminal justice, societal trauma, and gun regulation were extracted and compared across the case studies. The methodology focuses on identifying framing strategies, the use of language, and the broader socio-political contexts influencing these narratives.
United Kingdom: the 1996 Dunblane massacre
Context of the Dunblane Massacre
The Dunblane massacre occurred on the 13th of March 1996 at Dunblane Primary School in Scotland. The gunman, 43-year-old Thomas Hamilton, entered the school that morning and forced his way into the gymnasium, where a class of 28 primary one pupils were starting their P.E. lesson. Armed with legally acquired handguns, Hamilton rapidly opened fire, shooting indiscriminately. Fifteen children, all aged five, and their teacher were fatally shot in the gym, with another child dying en route to the hospital. In total, 16 people were killed and 15 others injured before Hamilton took his own life. Following the attack, the UK government introduced the Firearms (Amendment) Act 1997, initially banning all cartridge ammunition handguns above .22 calibre, followed by a subsequent ban on all handguns later that year.
Key findings in media and political response to the Dunblane massacre
- Evidence indicates that British right-leaning and left-leaning newspapers report mass shootings differently.
- The Telegraph frames gun violence primarily as a criminal justice issue, focusing on the opinions of security, political, and policing officials. Public health consequences receive little attention, and proposals for stricter firearm controls are frequently downplayed.
- The Guardian, in contrast, highlights gun violence as a public health crisis, emphasising the mental and physical effects. Health professionals’ perspectives are prioritised over those of police or security experts.
- Political divisions reflect similar differences: Labour politicians largely focus on public well-being to advocate for stronger gun regulation, while Conservative politicians emphasise law and order, centring discussions on illegal firearm acquisition and crime. Across party lines, the broader health impacts of gun violence, such as emergency room costs or the strain on mental health services, receive limited attention.
The Guardian’s response to the Dunblane massacre
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of public health
Doctors and emergency services personnel were regularly quoted in the reporting. The Guardian placed particular emphasis on the scale of the incident and the emergency response.
“Stirling Royal Infirmary sent seven doctors, supported by nurses and paramedics… Sixteen ambulances ferried casualties to the infirmary… Paramedics at the scene called a helicopter to pick up a critically injured girl. She was flown to the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre in Glasgow, from where a medical team took her to the nearby Yorkhill Children’s Hospital. Around 50 ambulancemen and paramedics were involved in the operation.” [1]
The decision to list the magnitude of the operation explicitly highlights the public health consequences of the shooting.
The reporting focused on both physical and mental trauma suffered by the victims and the responding emergency services. Additionally, The Guardian highlighted the long-term impact on the community.
“Jack Beattie, a senior consultant paediatrician, who arrived with the medical team, said it was the worst carnage he had witnessed in his 19 years as a doctor.” [2]
“Extra bars and bolts may increase the physical safety of schoolchildren, but the loss of psychological security may take longer to repair”.[3]
“a community, indeed, that would never forget this horrible interruption of their restful lives.” [4]
On the other hand, the Guardian rarely discussed the mental state of the attacker. When it is mentioned, academics and health experts are quoted as saying that mass killings are:
“put down to mental illness, but studies… have shown they are not mentally ill in the strict sense.” [5]
A common tactic to deflect calls for stricter gun control is to emphasise mental health as the primary cause of the shooting, shifting the focus away from firearm regulations and towards addressing mental health issues.[6] The Guardian appears to be pre-empting these arguments by dispelling myths surrounding mental health and mass shootings.
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Substantial space is dedicated towards the debate surrounding gun regulation. The reporting frequently employs concerning figures to support pro-gun control arguments.
“3 million arms are circulating, many without registration.” [7]
“The reason why the American homicide rate is 150 times as high as the British is due to the open availability of guns in the US compared to the UK. The main reason why we have such a low proportion of homicides caused by guns – only 10 per cent of the total – is our tight gun controls. Tighter controls would reduce them even further.”[8]
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of criminal justice
The Guardian does not refer to legal measures addressing criminality or rely on quotes from police. The issue appears to be framed as a public health issue rather than a law enforcement problem. Nevertheless, politicians are regularly quoted, particularly the leaders of the major political parties. This may be due to the timing of the mass shooting, a year before the 1997 general election. Other quoted politicians were more directly involved in the story, suggesting an intention to provide context rather than frame the narrative around legal measures and the rule of law.
“The Labour MP for Darlington, Alan Milburn, last year called for new curbs on gun licenses in the wake of the fatal shooting by a gun fanatic of his 15-year-old step-daughter.” [9]
“Shadow Scottish secretary, George Robertson, who lives in Dunblane and whose children attended the Dunblane primary. He described the murders as “an act of unspeakable brutality and woe.”” [10]
Improved security measures were regarded as insufficient. Discussions around reforming legal frameworks centre on gun control rather than framing police powers and school security as too lenient.
“Ministers are expected to introduce tougher measures to protect pupils against intruders soon, but they were under no illusion last night that school perimeters could be strengthened enough to prevent entry by a determined gunman.” [11]
“George Varvana, president of the National Association of Head Teachers, said improved security could provide only limited protection. ‘The person who killed these children did not need to gain entry to the school to do what he did. He might have opened fire into the playground through the school railings.’” [12]
Summary of the Guardian’s coverage of the Dunblane massacre
The Guardian’s coverage focuses on the mental and physical consequences of the shooting, emphasising the need for stricter firearm regulations. There is a noticeable absence of discussions surrounding police powers or physical security measures. As a result, gun violence is framed primarily as a public health issue rather than through a criminal justice lens.
The Telegraph‘s response to the Dunblane massacre
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of public health
The Telegraph quotes Doctors and emergency workers, although not as often and with less emphasis on the scale of the operation. Instead, reporting focuses on the victims’ injuries and ambulance workers’ eyewitness accounts. Alongside the Guardian, the Telegraph includes vivid descriptions of the injuries sustained. There is a reliance on quotes from emergency workers, family members of the victims and the victims themselves.
“Dr Hamish Finaly, director of clinical surgery, in his gown and operating mask, described the injuries the children had received. Three had been shot in the chest, one in the abdomen, three had sustained limb injuries, and one had been badly injured in the top of the leg. One child who died shortly after arriving at the hospital had been shot in the head”. [13]
“The first ambulancemen at the scene spoke last night of a ‘medieval vision of hell’”. [14]
The Telegraph highlights the tight-knit community in Dunblane but fails to acknowledge the long-term psychological impact of the shooting explicitly.
“Everyone knows everyone else. There is nobody who is not affected.” [15]
While ignoring societal mental well-being, significant attention is given to the mental status of the perpetrator, where homophobic insinuations are woven into sentences describing the attacker’s instability
“Thomas Hamilton was regarded by some children at the youth club he helped run as ‘weird’. That he was probably homosexual”. [16]
“With this kind of highly paranoid personality, there is an element of mental instability which it is impossible effectively to control.” [17]
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of gun regulation
In the Telegraph’s coverage, gun regulation receives little attention, and any mention of stricter firearm controls is quickly undermined. For example, discussions surrounding a gun amnesty were followed by:
“It would be extremely expensive to implement… But it is unlikely to have any effect on professional criminals, many of whom buy their weapons on the black market.” [18]
Unsubstantiated claims, such as this one, are widespared in the Telegraph’s reporting. Moreover, they direct the narrative towards criminality and lawlessness. There is an intentional underreporting of other forms of gun violence, including suicides, accidental shootings or cases involving domestic abuse.
British gun rights advocacy groups are frequently quoted, with their unchecked claims often positioned at the end of paragraphs.
“The National Pistol Association said… our members consider that controls over ownership of weapons are very tight, and we do not believe that further legislation would help.” [19]
In place of reporting on tighter gun control, the Telegraph focuses on the supposed societal decline and the normalisation of violence in today’s culture.
“Never in the history of mankind have so many people had such immediate access to images of violence with which to feed and corrupt their imagination… from the remorseless zapping of infantile movies through the stylised (and stylish) sadism of a film like Reservoir Dogs, or Natural Born Killers to the most vicious of video nasties.” [20]
“We have to ask ourselves whether this horror is not in some way a reflection of the sort of society we have made.” [21]
Additionally, the Telegraph emphasises the perceived powerlessness of officials and the broader community in addressing such random acts of violence.
“something as ghastly as this could not be prevented by reasonable methods.” [22]
“Sometimes we can reassure ourselves by pointing to some sort of social failure which has made peculiarly horrible crimes possible… there is apparently no reason to point the finger of blame at any other person or any authority. We are left with a mystery.” [23]
“Questions will be raised… about the availability of firearms… they are largely a therapeutic exercise. They help to preserve the illusion that all disasters are potentially preventable and all species of evil susceptible to cure.” [24]
This narrative, combined with limited reporting on gun regulation, promotes a sense of helplessness in addressing mass shootings. The prominent use of religious symbolism and quotations from religious figures reinforces this. The Telegraph frames the event as a random act of God rather than a preventable shooting enabled by a system that allowed the legal acquisition of weapons.
“We do not know why God let this horrendous thing happen and any quick answer would be glib.” [25]
In reference to Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov:
“A religious answer to Ivan’s question as he knows himself, is that suffering – even the suffering of children – is necessary for men to know the difference between good and evil.” [26]
In regard to reporting the Dunblane massacre through the prism of criminal justice
The Telegraph advocates for stricter legal measures to prevent future mass killings, framing the debate as having strong support for expanded police powers. The narrative suggests a growing consensus around the need for tougher enforcement to address such threats.
“The government has granted police powers to enter schools to search for knives or other offensive weapons. Yesterday’s murders will give additional urgency to a demand from some teachers’ leaders for tougher legal remedies against school intruders. At present, the maximum fine for trespass on school property is £50, and many heads say that police regard the offence as low-priority.” [27]
There is an emphasis on police inaction before the shooting rather than lenient firearm regulation.
“At a summer camp in Loch Lomond in 1988, there were claims that he had whipped boys with twigs. Strathclyde Police investigated, but the procurator fiscal took no action. On another occasion, Lothian and Border police cautioned him, but again took no further action.” [28]
Police and politicians are frequently quoted, reinforcing the notion that the issue is one of criminal justice. Moreover, particular focus was placed on physical security measures to prevent future violence.
“But security experts say such investment is unusual. Ken Cooper, a former assistant chief constable and security consultant to the Secondary Heads Association, said: “In general, schools have not been constructed to consider security but to provide an environment that is calm and civilised. Like many other organisations, they do not consider security a high priority. Attitudes are beginning to change, but there is a substantial way to go.” [29]
Summary of The Telegraph’s reporting on the Dunblane massacre
The Telegraph acknowledges the physical trauma and perspectives of emergency personnel but prioritises the criminal aspects of gun violence. The reporting places blame on lenient police and security measures, insufficient mental health support, and a culture that normalises violence. As a result, gun violence is framed as an issue of criminal justice and societal decline, with little focus on gun regulation or public health consequences.
Political Speeches and Government Reports on the Dunblane massacre
Background
Following the Dunblane massacre, the British Conservative government introduced the Firearms (Amendment) Act 1997, which banned the private possession of handguns, except for .22 calibre pistols. At the time, both Labour and the Liberal Democrats called for a complete ban on handguns. After Labour’s 1997 election victory, the new government swiftly passed the Firearms (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1997, outlawing .22 calibre pistols as well. Although Conservative frontbenchers opposed the legislation, it passed through the House of Commons and the House of Lords, coming into effect on January 1, 1998.
The issue of public health in political speeches and government reports on the Dunblane massacre
The newly elected Labour government emphasised public well-being during debates leading up to the vote on the 1997 Firearms (Amendment) (No. 2) Act, a bill the House of Commons passed with a second reading vote of 384 to 181.[30] The Home Secretary Jack Straw highlights that:
“The basis of principle [for this act] is the protection of the public.” [31]
“We must not forget the extent of public revulsion at the holding of handguns in general civilian use that followed not only Dunblane, but Hungerford. I have no doubt that Labour Members and quite a number of Conservative Members speak for the public and also have the public’s safety in mind.” [32]
“By banning all handguns, this short Bill will contribute greatly to public safety. It will meet the legitimate demands made to the House by many people since the events of Dunblane. To deny the public the protection that the Bill offers would be an abdication of our responsibility.” [33]
In contrast, conservative politicians rarely discuss the public health ramifications of gun violence, instead highlighting law and order. When Michael Howard, the former Home Secretary, rebuts Jack Straw’s arguments, he does so by shifting the conversation from public health to criminal justice:
“The need to protect the public should be the main priority of any Home Secretary—it certainly was mine. Protecting the public from gun-related crime was a priority of the last Government. We took firm action not only to ensure that we had some of the toughest gun controls in the world but to deal with the criminal misuse of illegally held firearms.” [34]
Gun violence is framed solely as a criminal issue by Conservative politicians who overlook the broader dangers posed by lenient gun regulation, such as accidental shootings and its role in suicides. Across the political spectrum, there was minimal, if any, discussion on the broader health consequences of gun violence, such as emergency room costs or the need for mental health services. Mental well-being was only addressed in relation to the perpetrator, with Labour MPs often challenging the argument pushed by pro-gun rights advocates that inadequate mental health care, rather than gun regulation, is the root issue. During a debate on gun control, Scottish Labour MP George Robertson referenced the Cullen Inquiry, a public report led by Lord Cullen investigating the causes and consequences of the Dunblane massacre. Robertson stated:
“There is no certain means of ruling out the onset of a mental illness of a type which gives rise to danger; or of identifying those whose personalities harbour dangerous propensities. On this ground alone it is insufficient protection for the public merely to tackle the individual rather than the gun.” [35]
The issue of gun regulation in political speeches and government reports on the Dunblane Massacre
Immediate reactions from Labour MPs focused on tightening firearm controls. During the parliamentary debate the day after the shooting, Labour MP George Robertson stated:
“We expect a thorough examination of, and any necessary action on, the present gun laws, which enabled such a man to own such a lethal armoury.” [36]
In contrast, officials from the Conservative government urged caution, advocating for waiting on findings from relevant committees and the inquiry. In response to Dafydd Wigley, leader of Plaid Cymru, who argued that:
“neither personal indulgences nor vested interests come before assuring the safety of communities and the avoidance of tragedies such as the one that happened yesterday,” [37]
The Prime Minister replied:
“There is of course a Firearms Consultative Committee that, as a statutory body, constantly keeps legislation under review. Its purpose is to review the Firearms (Amendment) Act 1988. I know that it issued a statement this morning saying that it does not propose to express a view on the matter in advance of the conclusions of the fatal accident inquiry”. [38]
This demonstrates Conservative officials’ propensity to shift the narrative from societal well-being to legal and procedural considerations. Additionally, Conservative MPs framed discussions on stricter gun regulation as excessive and infringing on individual rights. During the debate on the 1997 Firearms (Amendment) (No. 2) Act, then-Shadow Conservative Secretary Michael Howard stated:
“Where is the compelling need that must always be present if the state is to justify intervention in the otherwise lawful habits of law-abiding citizens?… The Conservative party believes that the principle of individual liberty that lies at the root of our democracy should compel any Government to take fully into account the views of minorities and minority interests.” [39]
A common theme in Tory politicians’ arguments was framing gun owners as ‘law-abiding citizens,’ steering the conversation toward legality and personal freedoms rather than addressing the public health concerns of gun violence.
The issue of criminal justice in political speeches and government reports on the Dunblane Massacre
The Conservative Government’s official response to the Cullen Inquiry prioritises law and order over public health concerns, framing gun violence primarily as a criminal justice issue.
“The Government intends to consult the police and other interested bodies on the stringent security standards which will be necessary to protect the public. These will be contained in guidance which the Government will issue and which will be enforced by the police.” [40]
Security measures and greater police powers are emphasised as the solution, suggesting the problem falls under criminal justice. Some Labour MPs challenged Conservatives who blamed failures in policing for the shooting.
“Some… say that everything was the fault of the Central Scotland police. The police, they say, did not implement the law, so we should pile the blame on one of the smallest police forces in the country. Then, apparently, we would have the solution to everything that happened… It is not sufficient, and never will be sufficient, to put the blame on an individual police force.” [41]
However, leading Labour politicians, including Jack Straw, do not shy away from the Conservative focus on criminality during debates on gun regulation. In addition to highlighting public well-being, Straw extensively critiques the Conservatives’ record on crime while discussing Dunblane:
“Having promised more law and better order, the Conservatives have delivered greater lawlessness and more disorder.” [42]
Moreover, Straw champions the police force, highlighting them as figures of authority who possess key insights into the gun control debate:
“We should listen carefully to the advice of the police, who know best about the dangers to society of the criminal use of weapons. Both the Police Federation and the Police Superintendents Association have come out in favour of a full and total ban.” [43]
By placing significance on the views of the police, Straw reinforces the narrative that gun violence is a criminal justice issue.
Summary
The newly elected Labour government prioritised public safety in discussions surrounding the 1997 Firearms (Amendment) (No. 2) Act, a bill aimed at banning all handguns. Labour frontbenchers, including Home Secretary Jack Straw, underscored the public’s demand for safety. In contrast, leading Conservatives framed gun violence primarily as a criminal justice issue, emphasising law enforcement over public health. Ultimately, the legislation passed with significant support, reflecting Labour’s influence in prioritising public health over criminality in the gun control discourse. While Labour held a considerable majority in the House of Commons, they also garnered votes from Plaid Cymru, the SNP, and the Liberal Democrats.[44] This indicates that Labour’s focus on public well-being effectively shaped legislative responses, while the Conservatives’ emphasis on individual rights and security reform appeared less impactful.
Key Actors Involved
The Snowdrop petition, referenced by Jack Straw during parliamentary debates: [45]
- A public campaign, launched in the aftermath of the Dunblane and Hungerford shootings, called for a total ban on the private ownership and use of handguns in the United Kingdom. Founded by friends of the bereaved families, the campaign garnered over 750,000 signatures in just six weeks. It also produced impactful adverts, including a 40-second film featuring a human-shaped target being annihilated with a .22 pistol, narrated by Sean Connery.[46] The campaign focused on public safety concerning gun violence rather than framing the issue around criminality and lawlessness. The Snowdrop campaign is widely recognised as having played a pivotal role in the implementation of the handgun ban.
The British Shooting Sports Council, referenced by MP Anne McGuire during parliamentary debates: [47]
- A pro-gun rights umbrella body encompassing all major shooting associations, intended to achieve consensus on political and legislative issues affecting shooting sports. Following the shooting, the organisation aimed to run advertisements placing blame on the police, intending to deflect responsibility from relaxed gun regulations. However, major national newspapers refused to run their advertisements.[48]
Target Gun magazine, referenced by George Robertson during parliamentary debates: [49]
- A pro-gun rights organisation that opposed the handgun ban and lobbied MPs. Readers were encouraged to write letters to their local representatives who would “feel the weight of the pro-gun post bag”. Moreover, free pro-gun rights literature was distributed to legislators, illustrating the substantial resources the gun lobby could leverage. [50]
The British Association for Shooting and Conservation, referenced by The Telegraph: [51]
- A pro-gun rights political lobbying organisation that opposed the handgun ban and advocated against what they perceived to be an emotionally driven “knee-jerk” reaction to the Hungerford and Dunblane shootings.[52]
The National Pistol Association, referenced by The Guardian.[53]
- A pro-gun rights organisation that highlighted what it perceived as already stringent measures required to gain access to shooting clubs.
Conclusion
The Guardian framed gun violence as a public health issue, emphasising community trauma and advocating for stricter firearm regulations. In contrast, the Telegraph and Conservative MPs approached gun violence as a criminal justice matter, focusing on policing, security, and citizens’ rights. While Labour did engage with the criminality aspect of gun violence and highlighted law enforcement perspectives, the party primarily emphasised public well-being in debates, although it stopped short of explicitly framing gun violence as a public health issue. Labour’s successful enactment of tighter gun regulations suggests that a public health-oriented framing can be an effective strategy for garnering legislative support. This is further supported by the Snowdrop campaign’s intensive lobbying, which cast gun violence as a public safety threat and played an essential role in generating public backing for stricter gun control.
United States of America: the 2017 Las Vegas massacre
Context
The Las Vegas shooting occurred on the 1st of October 2017, when 64-year-old Stephen Paddock fired into the crowd of the Route 91 Harvest music festival from the 32nd-floor suite of the Mandalay Bay Hotel. Using fourteen semi-automatic rifles, some equipped with bump stocks to increase their firing rate, Paddock unleashed 1,058 rounds, killing 60 people and injuring approximately 413. The ensuing panic raised the total number of injured to an estimated 867. Roughly an hour after the shooting, Paddock was found dead in his hotel room from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. In response to the attack, the U.S. government implemented a federal ban on bump stocks in 2018, prohibiting the sale and possession of devices that enable semi-automatic weapons to mimic automatic fire.
Framing Overview
- Evidence indicates that American right-leaning and left-leaning newspapers report mass shootings differently.
- The New York Times’ reporting emphasises the health consequences of the Las Vegas shooting, subsequently framing the gun violence narrative around public health and safety. The need to reform firearm legislation was a running theme within the reporting.
- Fox News, in contrast, downplays the public health consequences of the shooting, framing it instead as a criminal justice issue. Moreover, the reporting fails to address wider gun violence in America and consistently undermines calls for gun regulation, labelling gun control advocates as insensitive and exploitative.
- Statements by Democratic politicians mirror the New York Times coverage but go further in their condemnation of insufficient gun laws and the need to categorise US gun violence as a public health emergency. Conversely, Republican politicians avoid discussing broader gun violence and potential legislative reform, instead offering prayers and their condolences.
The New York Times‘ response to the Las Vegas massacre
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of public health
In most articles analysed, the perspectives of doctors and emergency professionals were largely overlooked, and information on the shooting’s public health impact was omitted. However, one New York Times article, titled “Controlled Chaos at Las Vegas Hospital Trauma Center After Attack,” specifically focused on the emergency response, detailing the scale of the operation, the number of victims treated, and the several hospitals working at full capacity.
“At Sunrise Hospital & Medical Center, within walking distance of the concert, 90 patients arrived in the first hours and by noon on Monday the total had reached 180. Of those, 124 “met the criteria for trauma activation,” said Dr. Jeffrey Murawsky, the hospital’s chief medical officer… On Monday afternoon, operating teams at Sunrise were still at work. More than 50 patients had undergone surgery… Dignity Health-St. Rose Dominican received 61 patients at its three campuses, 32 of them to the Siena location, a level-three trauma center.” [54]
Unlike the other New York Times articles analysed, this piece consistently quoted medical professionals and emergency personnel:
“I’ve been a nurse for 30 years, and this was by far the worst moment I’ve had, the worst injuries,” [55]
““They were exposed to significant trauma, things that are very very unusual — a lot of deaths, a lot of injury, a lot of hysteria in one place, a lot of tragedy, so quite frankly many of them will probably be dealing with this for the rest of their lives,” said Jeff Buchanan, a deputy fire chief with Clark County.” [56]
These accounts underscore the intense mental health impacts. Furthermore, vivid descriptions of the physical trauma suffered were a common theme in the reporting.
“It dawned on people when they heard screams, when they saw bloodied victims collapse around them, or when others stampeded for the exits, trampling some of the people in their way.” [57]
In most articles, perspectives from health officials were generally limited; however, some attention was given to public health impacts, especially the urgent need for blood donations and the extreme strain on nearby hospitals.
“The blood on the shelf when these tragedies occur is saving patients’ lives, and we need people to come back and replenish” [58]
“Ordinarily, the trauma center would take in eight to 10 traffic accident victims in a night… Dignity Health-St. Rose Dominican Hospital received 56 patients at its three campuses, including four who were in critical condition.” [59]
Consistently numbering and listing the number of victims, trauma cases, overwhelmed hospitals, and emergency responders suggests an authorial intent to underscore the scale and logistical demands of the public health response. This framing likely aims to highlight the immediate and long-term healthcare strain that arises from gun violence.
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Calls for stricter firearm measures were a running theme in the New York Times coverage of the Las Vegas shooting. Reporters outlined a list of moderate, politically viable measures and highlighted gun violence statistics to stress the urgency for reform.
“We are always likely to have higher gun death rates than Europe. But the scale is staggering. Since 1970, more Americans have died from guns (including suicides, murders and accidents) than the sum total of all the Americans who died in all the wars in American history, back to the American Revolution. Every day, some 92 Americans die from guns, and American kids are 14 times as likely to die from guns as children in other developed countries”. [60]
Evidence that implies public support for greater gun control was also presented, including quotes from public figures like Caleb Keeter, a performer at the event, whose views on stricter regulation changed following the tragedy:
“The performer whose views had shifted… said on Twitter on Monday that he had been “a proponent of the Second Amendment my entire life.” He added, “Until the events of last night.”” [61]
Notably, public health officials were championed when discussing gun control changes.
“But public health experts think it’s plausible that a series of well-crafted safety measures like these could reduce gun deaths by one-third—or more than 10,000 a year.” [62]
“We don’t need to simply acquiesce to this kind of slaughter. When Australia suffered a mass shooting in 1996, the country united behind tougher laws on firearms. As a result, the gun homicide rate was almost halved, and the gun suicide rate dropped by half, according to the Journal of Public Health Policy.” [63]
Alternatively, the views of police officials were not discussed regarding gun regulation.
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of criminal justice
The New York Times reporting pre-empts pro-gun rights advocates’ focus on criminal gun violence.
“Skeptics will say that there are no magic wands and that laws can’t make the carnage go away. To some extent, they’re right. Some criminals will always be able to obtain guns, especially in a country like America that is awash with 300 million firearms. We are always likely to have higher gun death rates than Europe. But the scale is staggering.” [64]
Of note was a lack of reporting on calls for expanding police powers or implementing physical security measures to prevent future mass shootings. Instead, the focus centred on advocating for changes to gun control legislation.
While public health and gun regulation narratives were prioritised, the New York Times frequently quoted police and security officials, indirectly framing the Las Vegas shooting – and gun violence more broadly – as a law enforcement issue.
“There is confusion over the next few minutes as officers arrive to scenes of death and mayhem. “It’s coming from upstairs in the Mandalay Bay. Upstairs in the Mandalay Bay, halfway up I see the shots coming from Mandalay Bay, halfway up.”… The gunman had smashed two windows that have a broad view of the festival ground, the sheriff said later at a news conference.” [65]
“Aaron Rouse, special agent in charge of the FBI office in Las Vegas, said, “We have determined to this point no connection with an international terrorist group.”” [66]
However, the references to police in the New York Times appear aimed at giving readers a clear account of the events and contextual details rather than endorsing a criminal justice perspective, such as questioning security officials on solutions to gun violence.
Summary
The New York Times’ framing of the Las Vegas shooting primarily depicts gun violence as a public health issue, highlighting the mental and physical ramifications, as well as the impact on health services. A recurring theme across the reporting is a call for gun control measures. Consequently, legislative reform – not increased police powers, security measures, or improved mental healthcare – is presented as the primary solution to gun violence.
Fox News‘s response to the Las Vegas massacre
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of public health
The reporting centres on the attacker’s instability, attributing the shooting to a potential mental illness:
“possibly a mental defect that was starting to surface. Quite possibly, even a medical problem.” [67]
Mental illness is presented as a rationale for the inevitability of such violence in a large population, conveying a sense of helplessness in the face of gun violence:
“the law-abiding people of this country, over 80 million people own guns in the United States. These are among the best people out there and there are warped, sick and evil individuals.” [68]
Unlike other news outlets, Fox provides limited descriptions of trauma and injuries, though it does highlight some public health impacts, such as hospitals at capacity, civilians transporting the wounded due to overloaded ambulance services, and large public turnout for blood donations:
“We’ve also heard tales of ordinary civilians stopping in their pickup trucks and other vehicles to help ferry the wounded to these hospitals, because the ambulance services were clearly so overwhelmed with well over 500 wounded. An urgent call went out earlier today too for blood donations and the people of Las Vegas”. [69]
However, Fox’s coverage features minimal interviews with health officials and none with emergency workers. Additionally, there is no discussion on the long-term mental health impact on survivors, first responders, or broader society.
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Fox’s coverage largely focuses on prayers, mourning, and criticism of those calling for gun regulation. Reporters repeatedly target Democrats, outspoken celebrities, and the ‘liberal media’ for rushing to politicise the tragedy, framing these calls for firearm reform as insensitive and exploitative.
“in the midst of tragedy, the rush to politicize the worst shooting in American history is shameful. Now, the left has no shame”. [70]
“Less guns don’t equal less terrorist, bottom line. It’s not the time or the place. Honor the dead, respect the dead. It’s about them today, it’s not about the shooter, it’s not about a gun. It’s not about politics, it’s about them.” [71]
Additionally, unchecked assertions claim that fewer guns do not equate to fewer mass shootings, promoting the idea that even without firearms, attackers would find other means for mass harm.
“if they desire to kill — INGRAHAM: They will. HANNITY: They will find a way. INGRAHAM: Trucks, vans, SUV’s, they will do it with knives. They won’t be able to take out 50 people with a knife but they will be able to make a pressure cooker bomb. What weapon you decide to use it as your own choice, if you are an evil person. He went with an intent to kill as many people as possible and unfortunately he could have killed a lot more with the weaponry that he had.” [72]
This rhetoric reinforces two common pro-gun rights narratives: that ‘guns don’t kill people, people do’, and that regulation cannot prevent those determined to kill. By shifting focus away from guns and toward personal intent, Fox undermines calls for tighter firearm regulations, suggesting instead that violence is an inevitable consequence of mental instability that laws cannot address.
The coverage also emphasises the Second Amendment and the ‘God-given right’ to self-defence, suggesting that more guns lead to greater safety. This narrative promotes the gun lobby’s well-worn adage that ‘more guns in the hands of good guys’ is the answer to gun violence.
“HANNITY: Here is a question, you know God forbid — I’ve always been a believer you’ve got to prepare to defend yourself… The 32nd floor where this guy is. This guy has a machine gun. How are they going to take them on without a weapon? Or if it’s happening within a crowd, if they were in San Bernardino, do you want Sean Hannity, who is trained in the safety and use of a firearm in that room? When they drop the clip and they start to reload you have a shot, you have a chance.” [73]
In regard to reporting the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of criminal justice
There is a strong emphasis on police interviews and quotes in Fox’s coverage, suggesting an intentional framing of gun violence as a criminal justice issue. When guests raise the topic of increased gun regulation, Fox reporters redirect to criminal gun violence and general lawlessness.
“Prior to 2011, we were average of mass shootings 200 times a day. Since 2015, we’re at 64 mass shootings per day… what is true here is that when you have hatred you cannot regulate that. You cannot regulate evil but you can regulate guns…MARC THIESSEN, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR: And they count everything that includes like four gang guys go out and have a shooting. Have a gang fight in Chicago, and that’s counted as a mass shooting. But that’s different than these kinds of mass shootings where you have somebody going out and attacking innocent civilians.” [74]
Accompanying the criminal justice narrative are suggestions that law enforcement errors contributed to the shooting, positioning greater police powers and security reform – not gun regulation – as the primary solution.
“So the question becomes as you hear these pleas for the NRA and for more laws, are the laws on the books good enough if they’re enforced, and are they not being enforced to the extent that they could be, Marc?” [75]
“we’re going to find someone along the way it was suspicious and they should’ve turned that suspicion into a phone call to law enforcement. It’s an incredible amount of premeditation to not go detected.” [76]
Finally, the suggestion of enhanced physical security measures further shifts the conversation from gun legislation to security-focused solutions.
“Should we have metal detectors at hotels? I mean, obviously, this guy was moving a lot of equipment in and out, should we change the way that we protect hotels, for example?” [77]
Summary
Fox’s reporting frames the Las Vegas shooting primarily as a criminal justice issue, downplaying its public health consequences. There is a noticeable absence of any discussions surrounding the physical and mental effects of gun violence. Additionally, reporters attribute the attack to the perpetrator’s mental instability and suggest that ineffective policing played a role. Fox’s coverage undermines calls for gun regulation, instead proposing increased security measures and the availability of more firearms as solutions to gun violence.
Political Speeches and Government Reports in response to the Las Vegas massacre
Background
Despite renewed pressure on US lawmakers to implement greater national gun control measures, comprehensive federal reform did not follow the Las Vegas shooting. However, bipartisan support emerged for a ban on bump stocks, the devices used in the attack to increase the rate of fire of semi-automatic weapons. Notably, the NRA supported administrative bump stock regulations,[78] and in 2018, the Trump administration redefined bump stocks as ‘machine guns’ under the National Firearms Act, effectively banning them without the need for congressional approval.
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of public health
Democratic representatives consistently frame gun violence as a public health crisis, emphasising the urgent need for action. Representative Pramila Jayapal stated:
“Gun violence is a public health crisis that has claimed thousands of innocent lives”. [79]
This view is echoed by Senator Chris Murphy, who stated:
“There is really no other country in the industrialized world that meets that rate of gun violence. The mass shootings, which get the most attention, are truly epidemic.” [80]
Similarly, Dick Durbin reinforces the public health narrative and underscores the potential to generate bipartisan support when framing gun violence in this manner:
“We have seen Democrats and Republicans join together to pass meaningful laws to deal with public health crises like opioid addiction. We have to do the same for this public health crisis.” [81]
In support of this perspective, Democratic representatives frequently reference public health organisations to strengthen the narrative that gun violence requires a public health response. Senator Ed Markey calls for increased resources for the CDC, emphasising:
“We must also recognize that this epidemic of gun violence is a public health emergency, and we must treat it that way. We must fully fund this critical research agenda at the Centers for Disease Control”. [82]
Further reinforcing this viewpoint, Senator Durbin notes the AMA’s stance on gun violence:
“The American Medical Association has declared that gun violence is a public health crisis in America. On an average day, 300 Americans are shot. About one-third of them will die from that gunshot.” [83]
Finally, democratic politicians address all forms of gun violence, shifting the gun violence narrative away from a criminal justice perspective. Senator Richard Blumenthal stated:
“Day after day, 92 Americans are killed as a result of gun violence, and 60 of them are suicides, but that is no less a death, and it is a preventable death if there are commonsense measures that will stop this carnage.” [84]
This focus contrasts sharply with the responses of Republican representatives, who avoid framing gun violence as a public health crisis. In both the House and Senate, many Republicans refrained from commenting on the Las Vegas shooting altogether, choosing instead to discuss other ongoing issues. Those who did address the event generally offered condolences, ‘thoughts and prayers’, and commended law enforcement and emergency responders for their service.
President Trump’s address following the shooting exemplifies this approach. While expressing gratitude to first responders, he avoids discussing the physical and mental trauma suffered by victims, responders, or the wider community. Moreover, there is no discussion about broader gun violence in America.
“I want to thank the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department and all of the first responders for their courageous efforts and for helping to save the lives of so many… We pray for the entire nation to find unity and peace, and we pray for the day when evil is banished and the innocent are safe from hatred and from fear.” [85]
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Improved and stricter gun control measures are recurring themes in Democrats’ discussions around the Las Vegas shooting, with a strong emphasis on the need for concrete action beyond offering prayers and condolences. Democratic politician, James Langevin, stated:
“prayers alone are not enough. We cannot, in good conscience, sit idly by as innocent people continue to die. Mr. Speaker, there are reasonable steps that we can take to make our communities safer, things like limiting high-capacity magazines and banning assault weapons”. [86]
Gun regulation is framed around public safety, reiterating the narrative that gun violence impacts community well-being and is a public health crisis. Senate minority leader and Democrat, Chuck Schumer, stated:
“What Congress can do and what Congress must do is to pass laws that keep our citizens safe, and that starts with laws that help prevent guns”. [87]
Gun regulation is framed as a solution to various forms of gun violence, extending beyond typical criminal activity. This approach underscores Democrats’ tendency to address gun violence as a broader societal issue rather than solely a matter of criminal justice. Senator Dianne Feinstein stated:
“Our laws permit criminal and domestic abusers to easily obtain weapons at gun shows and on the internet without a basic background check. We know background checks work. States that require background checks on private handgun sales see fewer women killed by their partners” [88]
Finally, democrats emphasise the public support for increased gun control measures.
“Ninety-two percent of Americans support expanded background checks.” [89]
“The public agrees. Just last year, a poll showed that 57 percent of Americans favor a ban on assault weapons.” [90]
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Las Vegas massacre through the prism of criminal justice
While much of the conversation around gun violence focuses on public health and safety, Democrats occasionally address the criminal use of firearms. Two days after the Las Vegas shooting, during a debate on legalising suppressors, Democrat Kirsten Gillibrand underscored the dangers these attachments pose to law enforcement and public safety:
“Our military is highly trained to use such weapons. It should not be easy for any person to buy a suppressor—known by many people as a silencer—to attach to their guns, which makes it harder for police to do their jobs and catch violent criminals.” [91]
It is plausible that Gillibrand is intentionally framing gun violence in this manner to generate bipartisan support against legalising suppressors. Nevertheless, a criminal justice narrative is minimal in Democrats’ statements following the shooting.
The few statements made by Republicans illustrate their propensity to centre the debate around law and order. By focusing on police experiences and referring to the perpetrator as an ‘outlaw’ and an ‘evil villain’, Republican Ted Poe frames gun violence as a criminal justice issue:
“The SWAT team quickly found the hiding place of the evil villain, and as they approached, the outlaw shot himself. Thus, he avoided a date with the hangman. Justice occurred.” [92]
Summary
Overall, political debates following the Las Vegas shooting centred on the ‘epidemic’ of gun violence affecting America. Democrats explicitly framed the shooting – and gun violence more broadly – as a critical public health issue, often referencing public health organisations to support their stance. Proposed solutions concentrated on stronger gun control measures. In contrast, statements framing gun violence as a criminal justice issue were minimal, likely due to Republican politicians’ reluctance to engage in discussions around gun violence and firearm regulation.
Key Actors Involved
National Rifle Association (NRA), referenced by the New York Times[93] and by Fox News. [94]
- A prominent gun-rights advocacy group with an extensive history of successfully lobbying Congress to minimise regulation on guns. Four days after the Las Vegas shooting, the NRA released a statement calling for tighter regulation on bump stocks. However, accompanying this concession were calls for relaxing laws around carrying concealed firearms. Political commentators suggest that the NRA advocated for the bump stock ban to take ‘the air out of the attack’ from Democratic legislators on greater gun regulation. [95] A similar argument suggests the NRA pushed for an administrative solution to avoid a congressional debate on gun control, which would likely draw greater public attention to gun legislation and potentially snowball into greater reform.
Centre for Disease Control, referenced by Democratic Senator Ed Markey. [96]
- A national public health agency in the US dedicated to protecting Americans from health, safety, and security threats. Around the time of the Las Vegas shooting, the CDC was effectively barred from researching gun violence due to the 1996 Dickey Amendment, heavily lobbied for by the NRA. This amendment mandates that “none of the funds made available for injury prevention and control at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) may be used to advocate or promote gun control.” [97] Since 2020, the Biden administration provided funding for the CDC to research gun violence. Currently, the CDC classifies firearm violence as a ‘serious public health problem’. [98]
The American Medical Association, referenced by Democratic Senator Dick Durbin. [99]
- A professional association that operates as a lobbying group made up of physicians and medical students. The AMA classified gun violence as a public health crisis following the Las Vegas shooting.
Conclusion
The New York Times’ reporting framed gun violence as a public health issue, underscoring the urgent need for stricter gun control measures. Democrats echoed this narrative, explicitly labelling gun violence as a public health crisis that can be mitigated through legislative firearm reform. Their arguments are strengthened through references to public health organisations, supporting the view that gun violence is a public health emergency.
In contrast, Fox News primarily framed the Las Vegas shooting as a criminal justice issue, downplaying the public health implications of gun violence. However, a central focus of the reporting was to undermine calls for gun regulation, portraying it as insensitive and exploitative. Republicans seemingly aligned with this view as they showed a reluctance to engage in discussions about firearm legislation or gun violence following the shooting. Moreover, the NRA actively lobbied to prevent Congressional debates on gun regulation, advocating for administrative action on bump stocks. Accordingly, pro-gun advocates’ focus following the shooting centred on suppressing political momentum and discourse around gun control rather than focusing on framing gun violence as a criminal justice issue.
Australia: the 1996 Port Arthur massacre
Narrative
The Port Arthur massacre occurred on the 28th of April 1996, when 28-year-old Martin Bryant opened fire in and around the historic Port Arthur site in Tasmania, Australia. Armed with a semi-automatic rifle, Bryant began his attack in a café, moving through the area and shooting at random. Within minutes, he had killed 35 people and wounded 23 others, marking one of the deadliest mass shootings in Australian history. Bryant was apprehended the following day after a standoff with police. The tragedy led to sweeping changes in Australian gun laws, including a federal ban on semi-automatic rifles and shotguns, and the introduction of a national firearm buyback program
Framing Overview
· Australian right-leaning and left-leaning newspapers’ narratives on gun violence did not diverge significantly when reporting on the Port Arthur mass shooting.
· Sydney Morning Herald extensively covered the public health consequences of the shooting, including mental and physical trauma to victims, emergency responders and the wider community. Public health organisations and officials were regularly cited alongside calls for greater gun control.
· The Australian Financial Review – while not as explicit – framed gun violence as a public health challenge, linking gun regulation with concerns for community well-being.
· Political perspectives aligned closely with the Australian Financial Review, offering an implicit public health narrative. Politicians acknowledged gun violence as a threat to community safety but stopped short of discussing its direct impacts on public health. Discussions on gun regulation similarly strike a balance, as politicians acknowledge various contributing factors to gun violence (mental health and societal issues) while still advocating for stricter firearm controls.
Sydney Morning Herald’s response to the Port Arthur massacre
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of public health
The Sydney Morning Herald gives significant attention to the public health consequences of the shooting, particularly the lasting mental trauma faced by victims and healthcare professionals.
“We have a full team of support staff and counsellors that are looking after the psychological wellbeing of the victims… Some of the hospital staff had received trauma counselling: “I think the impact on staff – to be honest, now that yesterday’s episode is over – is one of disbelief”” [100]
The report extends this focus to the broader public, acknowledging the widespread psychological impact of the Port Arthur tragedy.
“Dr Victor Storm, one of the Strathfield massacre counselling team and chair of the Faculty of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the Royal Australian New Zealand College of Psychiatry, says the effects of Port Arthur will be far-reaching. “Every time (something like) this occurs, it does reawaken the memories some people have managed to deal with”. [101]
The frequent reliance on quotations from doctors, public health organisations and emergency responders to the shooting reiterates the newspaper’s focus on public health and societal well-being.
“preliminary results of a State-wide survey of 16,000 urban and rural residents commissioned by the Department of Health and released last month found 92 per cent of urban residents and 83 per cent of rural residents supported annual registration of guns.” [102]
“Professor Beverley Raphael, director of the Centre for Mental Health and acting chief health officer in the NSW Health Department, said the shooting showed the need for tighter gun control.” [103]
Similar to the Guardian’s reporting, the Sydney Morning Herald challenges the notion that mental illness is the primary cause of mass shootings, countering a frequently used tactic by the gun lobby to divert focus from gun control towards mental health.
“Feelings of failure, anger and impotence are common in such killers, but these features alone are usually insufficient to cause aggressive behaviour resulting in multiple and apparently purposeless deaths. Few are mentally ill, or, indeed, have any clearly diagnosable psychiatric disorder. Even the presence of psychosis would be unlikely, of itself, to account for such actions.” [104]
“Such killers, who are invariably male, are unlikely to be mentally ill but are likely to have achieved very little and, as a result, harbour grudges and resentment that can develop into violent fantasies, according to the experts.” [105]
Finally, when addressing civil liberties and the right to own firearms, the Sydney Morning Herald centres on public health and societal well-being. Accordingly, gun regulation and gun violence continue to be framed as a public health issue.
“we must balance one person’s “freedom” against the harm (and, importantly here, the potential harm) it poses to others in the community. It is a mind-boggling understatement to say that the harm being caused by too-easy access to these weapons (for whatever reason) is surely tipping the balance towards curtailing the “freedom” to own these weapons. It is surely time to stand up for our rights as non-gun owners to live our lives without the threat of being murdered en masse by someone who is armed and who has lost the plot.” [106]
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of gun regulation
The Sydney Morning Herald highlights public support for stricter gun control, referencing pro-gun control groups, polling data, and quotes from public figures. These sources underscore a demand for change. Additionally, they challenge pro-gun rights tropes like ‘guns don’t kill people, people kill people’ and counter statements that minimise the role of regulation, particularly arguments against legislating that reference mental instability.
“In the immediate aftermath of the appalling Tasmanian massacre we have had to suffer yet another fatuous statement from John Tingle: “You can’t legislate against insanity.” No, Mr Tingle, you can’t, but what you can do is legislate to keep guns, and particularly high-powered semi-automatic rifles, out of the hands of the insane and the potentially insane, which includes all of us.” [107]
Furthermore, the article dismisses the notion that immediate tragedy is an inappropriate time to address gun regulation, citing it as an opportune moment for change.
“They’ll tell you that immediately after a shooting tragedy is not an appropriate time to reconsider gun laws. They’re wrong because decades of inaction have proved that our legislators will sit on their hands rather than (no pun intended) bite the bullet unless popular outrage stirs them into action.” [108]
An explicit mention of public health accompanies the argument for stricter regulations, showing the Sydney Morning Herald’s framing of gun violence as a public health crisis rather than merely a criminal justice issue.
“the tragedy would prove a watershed for the gun control movement. “There will be an overwhelming push to tighten gun laws here and across Australia,” he said. “The power of the gun lobby in this State is finished. From now on this State’s gun laws will be based on a policy of public health and not on the basis of appeasing the gun lobby.”” [109]
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of criminal justice
The Sydney Morning Herald’s coverage presents gun violence as a societal rather than purely criminal issue, challenging common pro-gun arguments and pushing against the criminal justice-focused response often favoured by gun rights advocates. The newspaper critiques the notion that gun violence is solely a problem of ‘criminals’ obtaining weapons, emphasising that mass shootings frequently involve legally armed individuals.
“The argument (if it can even be described as an argument) that “the criminals will always get guns” is missing the point entirely: it is not “criminals” who run amok with these weapons – we all know that by now through bitter experience, don’t we? And, yes, people will certainly continue to kill with knives or clubs, or even their bare hands, but we all also know that the task of killing will not be as terrifyingly simple as it is with a high-powered semi-automatic rifle.” [110]
Furthermore, the newspaper dismisses calls for greater punitive measures in response to gun violence, arguing that such solutions fail to address the broader, systemic problem of easy gun access.
“Instead of calling for death penalties for offenders, which solve nothing and serve to only further brutalise our society, State premiers should call the bluff of the gun lobby, cease their endless platitudinous condolences to the families of the victims and hold a nationwide referendum on gun ownership.” [111]
Highlighting data from the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics, the Sydney Morning Herald underlines that gun violence is not invariably tied to crime rates, advocating for stricter firearm regulation as a preventive measure.
“Dr Don Wedderburn said it was ironic that Australia’s worst gun massacre had occurred in Tasmania – the State with the lowest crime rate. It was proof, once again, of the need for national control laws”. [112]
Summary
The Sydney Morning Herald emphasises the public health ramifications of gun violence, particularly the lasting mental trauma experienced by victims and healthcare professionals. The report highlights a strong public call for stricter gun control, countering pro-gun arguments and stressing that mass shootings often involve legally owned firearms. By framing gun violence as a societal issue rather than solely a criminal one, the newspaper advocates for legislation focused on public health, challenging the gun lobby and underscoring the need for national control laws.
The Australian Financial Review’s response to the Port Arthur massacre
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of public health
The Australian Financial Review refrains from detailing the events of the Port Arthur shooting, instead concentrating on the political and public responses to the massacre. Consequently, there is a significant omission of the mental and physical trauma experienced by the victims and the wider community. Moreover, the analysed articles lack references to public health organisations, medical professionals, or emergency personnel. Nevertheless, rather than solely framing gun violence as a criminal issue, the reporting acknowledges its broader, multifaceted nature. Regarding manual and semi-automatic firearms, the Australian Financial Review states:
“These weapons may be less capable of causing the kind of carnage seen in Tasmania. But they are still perfectly capable of turning a domestic argument or a fit of depression into a tragedy.” [113]
“Most fatal gun wounds in Australia are self-inflicted. The great majority of homicides are committed (about 80 per cent) by the spouses, lovers or friends of the victims. In most cases, they are the result of altercations. The evidence from Europe and the US suggests that the level of gun ownership is a significant determinant of the rate of homicide.” [114]
By highlighting domestic violence and suicide, the reporting provides a holistic view of gun violence, showcasing the issue as a threat to public health.
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Calls for stricter gun control legislation dominated the reporting, with the need for comprehensive, federal firearm reform reiterated throughout.
“We need not wait decades for recalcitrant States to agree on uniform laws.” [115]
The justification for gun reform is framed around societal well-being, prioritising a public health narrative over law and order.
“After recent events surely we are entitled to weigh the social costs entailed in lax gun laws whose purpose is to accommodate the peculiar fetish of a noisy minority who derive pleasure from shooting living things.” [116]
Alongside gun control, reporting highlights the need for Australia to reflect and improve its relationship with cultural violence and mental health – factors attributed to gun violence by Prime Minister Howard, who’s cited heavily by the Financial Review.
“He said the causes of the Port Arthur massacre went deeper than the inadequacy of gun control laws, and said Canberra would consider the impact of TV and video violence and of ‘contemporary attitudes towards the treatment of mental health problems’.” [117]
In regard to reporting on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of criminal justice
The reporting did not frame gun violence as a criminal or law enforcement issue. Police or security officials are not referenced. There was no discussion about enhanced physical security measures, greater police powers or harsher punishments to address gun violence. Finally, pro-gun advocates’ views were not represented in the reporting.
Summary
Overall, the Australian Financial Review frames gun violence as a public health issue. Community well-being is emphasised when discussing gun regulation. Moreover, reporting does not fixate on orthodox criminal violence, instead discussing the threat guns pose to public safety through suicides and domestic abuse.
Political Speeches and Government Reports responses to the Port Arthur massacre
Background
After the Port Arthur massacre, Prime Minister John Howard quickly reformed Australia’s gun control laws. Public outcry and bipartisan support in parliament culminated in the National Firearms Agreement (NFA), a 1996 gun regulation framework that banned civilian ownership of semi-automatic and pump-action firearms. The NFA also enforced strict licensing and registration requirements and launched a compulsory buyback program, resulting in hundreds of thousands of firearms being surrendered.
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of public health
In politicians’ speeches and debates, emergency personnel – both paramedics and police – are frequently acknowledged and commended for their response efforts. Of note is the emphasis placed on the mental health repercussions for the first responders and the broader community. Prime Minister, John Howard stated:
“An event such as this—the awful task of collecting bodies and arranging identification by grieving next of kin—places an enormous emotional strain on people involved.” [118]
Alongside this, a public health narrative appears in discussions surrounding gun control, where the conversation focuses on collective well-being and the role of gun regulation in reducing community harm. Several politicians across the political spectrum emphasise the societal impacts of gun violence and advocate for preventative measures to protect public health and community safety.
“understanding on the depth of community feeling on this issue and a desire, as I find it amongst my fellow Australians to grab this very tragic moment to bring about a profound cultural shift in the attitude of this community towards the possession and the use of destructive weapons, and perhaps if we do that as a community, we can avoid some of the trauma experienced almost as a daily fact of life in the United States.” [119]
“The decision taken by the Government is taken because we are committed to generating a safer Australian community, and that is an aspiration.” [120]
The frequent referencing of emergency personnel and emphasis placed on community well-being aligns with a public health narrative of gun violence. However, this framing remains less explicit than if politicians had directly referenced public health officials or organisations. Moreover, the burden on health services caused by the shooting, or gun violence more generally, is not discussed.
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of gun regulation
Politicians’ discussions of gun violence emphasise mental health and cultural factors as causes yet do not rule out the importance of gun control measures. Instead, the discourse suggests that a multifaceted approach is essential, with reforms to address social and mental health issues alongside stricter firearm regulation. Prime Minister, John Howard, stated:
“The causes of that dreadful event lie deeper than simply the inadequacy of our gun control laws, they go to aspects of the kind of society that we are. They go to issues concerning violence on the screen and in videos. They also, in the view of many of my colleagues on this side of the House – and they are views that I share – raise legitimate questions about contemporary attitudes towards the treatment of mental health problems”. [121]
Additionally, the leader of the opposition, Kim Beazley, argued:
“this is not a matter that will be resolved by better gun laws alone. There are other elements of the culture, other problems and mental health issues raised here that we need to consider.” [122]
This marks a distinct change, as mental health and gun violence are not used to preclude discussions around gun control but rather accompany them. These views are shared across Australia’s political divide.
In regard to political speeches and government reports on the Port Arthur massacre through the prism of criminal justice
Prime Minister John Howard acknowledged the burden placed on gun owners following the decision to tighten gun regulation but stressed that these measures aimed to enhance public safety:
“they are decisions that will inconvenience, they will influence the activities of people who hitherto have engaged in law-abiding pursuits.” [123]
“its always a sombre moment in a country where you ask the people who have done the right thing to put up with inconvenience because a limited number of people have done the wrong thing, but that is the nature of a democratic society. As somebody who is a fervent opponent of regulation, I always feel uncomfortable in responding to a problem with new laws and I think this is an occasion where if we didn’t, we wouldn’t be matching the national concern, we wouldn’t be matching the national need.” [124]
Accordingly, the Prime Minister is prioritising public well-being over law enforcement considerations in relation to gun violence as he continually references gun owners as law-abiding citizens and yet is still introducing national bans on certain firearms:
“And he said something with which I totally agree. He said that he and his fellow shooters were not criminals, they were Australians.” [125]
“at no stage have I sought to describe or categorise the attitude of people who enjoy shooting or people who are shooters as being in any way criminal or un-Australian.” [126]
Politicians do acknowledge police officials’ perspectives on gun regulation and gun violence, situating the discussion into the realm of criminal justice and the rule of law. However, this appears to be an eventuality as the NFA’s buyback program invariably involves the police force’s approval. Leader of the opposition, Kim Beazley, stated:
“I congratulate the Prime Minister on bringing forward the meeting of police ministers. We wish him well at that. We were not successful with the police ministers in our efforts to get from them national gun laws.” [127]
Summary
Public health is a central focus in Australian politicians’ discussions of gun violence, with community well-being prioritised over civil liberty and criminal justice concerns. Politicians often frame gun violence subtly, emphasising its threat to community safety rather than discussing its direct impact on public health. This approach may reflect a desire to build broad public support without alienating law enforcement personnel, as their cooperation was crucial for implementing the NFA. Discussions on gun regulation similarly strike a balance, as politicians acknowledge various contributing factors to gun violence – such as mental health and societal issues – while still advocating for stricter firearm controls.
Key Actors Involved
The National Coalition for Gun Control, referenced by the Sydney Morning Herald. [128]
– Known now as Gun Control Australia, the NCGC is an organisation that advocates for tighter gun laws and played a transformative role in Australia’s firearm legislative reform following the Port Arthur shootings. Central to the NCGC’s success was Rebecca Peters, who, as chair of the NCGC at the time, worked closely with government figures to drive legislative change.[129] Notably, the NCGC’s efforts received strong support from public health academics, who helped frame gun violence as a critical public health issue, shifting the conversation toward community well-being and safety. [130]
The Shooter’s Party, referenced by the Sydney Morning Herald. [131]
– Formed in May 1992 by journalist John Tingle, the party was established to oppose increased gun regulation. At the time of the Port Arthur shooting, the party held one seat in the New South Wales Legislative Assembly, occupied by Tingle himself. Tingle was vocal in his opposition to the government’s decision to reform Australia’s gun laws following the massacre and framed the gun control issue purely in terms of law and order. In the Sydney Morning Herald, Tingle focused his discussion of gun regulation and firearm registration on the violent, criminal misuse of guns, stating:
“There is a need to differentiate between the vast number of illegally or criminally-owned firearms, and the legally-owned firearms in the hands of law-abiding citizens.” [132]
– This perspective reflects a common stance among pro-gun lobbyists, as Simon Chapman, a member of the NCGC, notes:
“For Tingle, it followed that any measures designed to make guns less accessible to the general population should be opposed, while measures designed to punish those who had already misused guns should be supported… this convenient division of gun owners into safe versus dangerous, good versus bad, bears little resemblance to the facts about gun violence.”[133]
Police Ministers Council, referenced by the opposition leader, Kim Beazley. [134]
– The Police Ministers Council is comprised of police ministers from all of Australia’s states and territories and the Australian Attorney-General. Its purpose is to improve policy outcomes, ensuring the safety and security of Australians. The council played a crucial role in implementing the National Firearm Agreement.
Conclusion
Both left- and right-leaning Australian newspapers framed gun violence as a public health issue, although with varying emphasis. The Sydney Morning Herald focused on the mental and physical consequences of gun violence to justify stricter gun control measures. The Australian Financial Review offered a more implicit public health narrative, emphasising community well-being when discussing legislative firearm reform. Notably, the Financial Review emphasised insufficient mental healthcare and cultural deficiencies as causes behind gun violence, detracting from the central focus on greater gun control. Australian politicians across the political spectrum aligned with this view, recognising mental health and societal factors as contributing elements, but placing public health and firearm legislation reform as central themes when discussing gun violence. The shared narratives between Australia’s political and media landscapes likely helped foster public support for stricter gun control, ultimately facilitating the swift implementation of the National Firearm Agreement – just 12 days after the massacre.
Central Conclusion: cultural differences in media and political narratives following a mass shooting
The left-leaning UK newspaper consistently highlighted the public health ramifications of mass shootings and broader societal gun violence. Similarly, their US counterpart framed gun violence as a public health concern but did so less consistently, confining discussions on this topic to a single article. Instead, greater emphasis was placed on gun regulation, which emerged as the prevailing theme across all NYT articles analysed. Of the three left-leaning newspapers, the Sydney Morning Herald goes furthest in explicitly labelling gun violence as a public health issue. The reporting directly challenges the link between criminality and gun violence and highlights the mental and physical trauma suffered by victims of gun violence and the broader community. This narrative is powerfully interwoven into calls for greater gun control.
The right-leaning US media goes furthest in its portrayal of gun violence as a criminal justice issue, omitting the public health impact of the mass shooting and undermining calls for stricter gun regulation. In the UK, reporting is slightly more balanced, acknowledging victims’ trauma and quoting health personnel. However, it attributes blame to the police, inadequate mental health support, and a culture of violence. Consequently, gun violence is framed as a matter of criminal justice and societal decline, with minimal focus on gun regulation or public health implications. The Australian Financial Review diverts from its right-leaning US and UK media counterparts by portraying Australian gun violence as a complex public health challenge rather than solely a criminal justice issue. While it does not go as far as left-leaning newspapers, justification for stricter gun regulation relies on community well-being and safety. Furthermore, unlike US and UK right-wing newspapers, there is no mention of physical security measures or greater police powers as the panacea to mass shootings. Ultimately, the Australian Financial Review’s narrative aligns more closely with left-leaning reporting.
Across the US and the UK, a dichotomy emerged in how progressive and conservative politicians framed gun violence following mass shootings. In the UK, Labour politicians emphasised public well-being when advocating for tighter gun regulation. Conversely, Tory MPs favoured maintaining the status quo following the initial Firearm Amendment Act, framing gun violence through a criminal justice lens. In the US, Democrats went further than Labour, citing public health organisations and describing gun violence as a national ‘epidemic’. By contrast, no Republicans acknowledged the prevalence of gun violence in America, and the few who discussed the Las Vegas shooting employed a criminal justice narrative. However, in Australia, this pattern diverged significantly. Despite representing the nation’s largest conservative party, John Howard framed gun violence as a public health issue in response to the Port Arthur massacre, a stance echoed by members of the opposition. Unlike the more explicit public health narratives in the UK and the US, this messaging was subtler but centred on public safety as the driving force behind stricter firearm legislation.
Policy Recommendations
Based on the findings in Discourse Analysis: Global Gun Violence and Health, AOAV offers the following policy recommendations to address gun violence through evidence-based, public health-focused approaches:
- Adopt Public Health Framing in Gun Violence Policy
Governments should approach gun violence as a public health crisis, emphasizing its mental, physical, and societal impacts. Framing gun violence in this way, as seen in Australia’s response to the Port Arthur massacre, fosters public and bipartisan support for comprehensive firearm legislation. Public health organisations should play a central role in shaping and advocating for such policies. - Strengthen International Cooperation on Gun Regulation
Countries must collaborate on harmonising firearm laws, enforcing stricter controls on the sale and distribution of firearms, and tackling the black market trade. Lessons from the UK’s post-Dunblane reforms and Australia’s National Firearms Agreement demonstrate the effectiveness of coordinated national policies in reducing gun-related deaths. - Invest in Community and Victim Support Services
The long-term psychological impact of gun violence on survivors, families, and first responders highlights the urgent need for accessible trauma counselling and mental health services. Governments should allocate funding to ensure these services are widely available and prioritised in post-crisis responses. - Address the Role of Media in Shaping Gun Violence Narratives
Media outlets must adopt responsible reporting practices that avoid sensationalism and instead emphasise the systemic causes and impacts of gun violence. Policymakers should engage with media organisations to promote narratives that highlight the public health consequences and societal costs of firearm proliferation. - Integrate Mental Health into Gun Control Policies Without Deflection
Mental health considerations should complement, not replace, discussions of gun regulation. Evidence from this analysis shows that using mental illness as a sole explanatory factor diverts attention from the role of firearms. Policymakers must ensure that mental health reforms are part of a broader strategy that includes robust gun control measures. - Support Research into Gun Violence as a Public Health Issue
Governments and international bodies should fund research into the public health impacts of gun violence, particularly its long-term societal costs. This includes reinstating the ability of organisations like the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to study firearm-related injuries and deaths comprehensively. - Develop Comprehensive Gun Buyback and Licensing Schemes
Successful initiatives like Australia’s buyback programme post-Port Arthur demonstrate the potential to reduce firearm circulation. AOAV recommends implementing national buyback schemes alongside stringent licensing and registration requirements to limit civilian access to firearms. - Promote Education and Advocacy for Firearm Safety
Public education campaigns, akin to the UK’s Snowdrop petition, can mobilise public support for gun control. Advocacy should focus on the preventable nature of gun violence and the societal benefits of tighter regulations, drawing on evidence from comparative studies.
These recommendations underscore AOAV’s commitment to advocating for policies that prioritise public safety, address the root causes of gun violence, and reduce the harm caused by firearms globally.
Footnotes
[1] The Guardian (1996) ‘‘A boy pointed at a bullet hole in his arm. He couldn’t cry’: The medics Counselling offered to staff after trauma of 999 response’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[2] The Guardian (1996) ‘Massacre of the infants: The children who died’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[3] The Guardian (1996) ‘Security hopes shattered: Prevention Bars and bolts no protection against extreme violence’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[4] The Guardian (1996) ‘A darkness falls on the disbelieving town: Andrew O’Hagan on how a world that most thought was somewhere else came home to the people of Dunblane’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[5] The Guardian (1996) ‘Fantasies turn to awful reality: The killers Studies suggest frustration and failure motivate mass murderers’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[6] The Economist (2013) ‘Why the NRA keeps talking about mental illness, rather than guns’ accessed 16 October 2024.
[7] The Guardian (1996) ‘Police urged amnesty on Howard as firearm numbers grew: Gun control 3 million arms are circulating, many without registration’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[8] The Guardian (1996) ‘Guns kill, not just people: Serious gaps in firearms control need plugging’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[9] The Guardian (1996) ‘Guns and access top of agenda: Politics Shocked MPs pull back from knee-jerk response’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[10] The Guardian (1996) ‘Massacre of the infants: The children who died’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[11] The Guardian (1996) ‘Security hopes shattered: Prevention Bars and bolts no protection against extreme violence’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[12] Ibid.
[13] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Mothers could only wait and pray’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[14] Ibid.
[15] Ibid.
[16] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Reasons why a Scottish gym became a killing ground’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[17] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Heads call for urgent review of security’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[18] Ibid.
[19] Ibid.
[20] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Reasons why a Scottish gym became a killing ground’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[21] Ibid.
[22] The Telegraph (1996) ‘They were in the school gym when the gunman opened fire. Three minutes later 16 children lay dying’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[23] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Reasons why a Scottish gym became a killing ground’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[24] The Telegraph (1996) ‘The murder of children’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[25] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Dazed town bares its wounded heart’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[26] The Telegraph (1996) ‘The murder of children’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[27] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Heads call for urgent review of security’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[28] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Reasons why a Scottish gym became a killing ground’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[29] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Heads call for urgent review of security’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[30] BBC (1997) ‘MPs vote to ban all handguns’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[31] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 295 col. 1162, 11 June 1997. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[32] Ibid. col. 1167.
[33] Ibid. col. 1170.
[34] Ibid. col. 175.
[35] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 285 col. 251, 12 November 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[36] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 273 col. 1109, 14 March 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[37] Ibid. col. 1103.
[38] Ibid.
[39] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 295 col. 1172, 11 June 1997. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024.
[40] UK Government (1996) ‘The Public Inquiry into the Shootings at Dunblane Primary School on 13 March 1996: The Government Response’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[41] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 285 col. 252, 12 November 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[42] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 284 col. 349, 28 October 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[43] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 295 col. 1169, 11 June 1997. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[44] The Public Whip (2003) ‘Firearms (Amendment) Bill — 11 Jun 1997’, accessed 24 October 2024.
[45] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 284 col. 346, 28 October 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[46] Independent (1997) ‘Snowdrop withers but battle to curb guns lives on’, accessed 24 October 2024.
[47] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 295 col. 1176, 11 June 1997. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[48] Campaign (1996) ‘NEWS: Newspapers refuse to carry Dunblane ad from gun lobby’, accessed 24 October 2024.
[49] Hansard HC Deb. vol. 285 col. 251, 12 November 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 17 October 2024].
[50] Ibid.
[51] The Telegraph (1996) ‘Heads call for urgent review of security’, accessed 17 October 2024.
[52] Ibid.
[53] The Guardian (1996) ‘Police urged amnesty on Howard as firearm numbers grew: Gun control 3 million arms are circulating, many without registration’, accessed 16 October 2024.
[54] The New York Times (2017) ‘Controlled Chaos at Las Vegas Hospital Trauma Center After Attack’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[55] Ibid.
[56] Ibid.
[57] The New York Times (2017) ‘A Burst of Gunfire, a Pause, Then Carnage That Would Not Stop in Las Vegas’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[58] The New York Times (2017) ‘Blood Donation Lines for Las Vegas Shooting Victims Stretch for Blocks’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[59] The New York Times (2017) ‘A Burst of Gunfire, a Pause, Then Carnage That Would Not Stop in Las Vegas’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[60] The New York Times (2017) ‘Preventing Mass Shootings Like the Vegas Strip Attack’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[61] The New York Times (2017) ‘Country Stars React to Las Vegas Shooting: ‘I Cannot Express How Wrong I Was’’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[62] The New York Times (2017) ‘Preventing Mass Shootings Like the Vegas Strip Attack’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[63] Ibid.
[64] Ibid.
[65] The New York Times (2017) ‘Las Vegas Shooting: Chaos at a Concert and a Frantic Search at Mandalay Bay’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[66] The New York Times (2017) ‘Multiple Weapons Found in Las Vegas Gunman’s Hotel Room’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[67] Fox News (2017) ‘Doctors describe horrific scene in Las Vegas emergency rooms; At least 57 dead and 827 injured in Las Vegas massacre’, accessed 28 October 2017.
[68] Fox News (2017) ‘Las Vegas Massacre, 59 Dead, 527 Injured In Las Vegas Shooting; White House On Las Vegas Shooting; Awaiting Police News Conference On Las Vegas Shooting’, accessed 29 October 2017.
[69] Ibid.
[70] Ibid.
[71] Ibid.
[72] Ibid.
[73] Ibid.
[74] Fox News (2017) ‘Doctors describe horrific scene in Las Vegas emergency rooms; At least 57 dead and 827 injured in Las Vegas massacre’, accessed 28 October 2017.
[75] Ibid.
[76] Ibid.
[77] Ibid.
[78] The New York Times (2017) ‘N.R.A. Supports New Rules on ‘Bump Stock’ Devices’, accessed 29 October 2024.
[79] US House of Representatives (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 7652.
[80] US Senate (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 6252.
[81] Ibid. Page 6254.
[82] Ibid. Page 6248.
[83] Ibid. Page 6253.
[84] Ibid. Page 6266.
[85] Vox (2017) ‘Read Trump’s full speech on the Las Vegas shooting’, accessed 2 November 2024.
[86] US House of Representatives (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 7652.
[87] US Senate (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 6240.
[88] Ibid. Page 6258.
[89] Ibid. Page 6248.
[90] Ibid. Page 6258.
[91] Ibid. Page 6265.
[92] US House of Representatives (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 7652.
[93] The New York Times (2017) ‘Country Stars React to Las Vegas Shooting: ‘I Cannot Express How Wrong I Was’’, accessed 27 October 2024.
[94] Fox News (2017) ‘Doctors describe horrific scene in Las Vegas emergency rooms; At least 57 dead and 827 injured in Las Vegas massacre’, accessed 28 October 2017.
[95] CNN (2017) ‘The NRA’s strategic ploy on bump stocks’, accessed 4 November 2024.
[96] US Senate (2017) ‘Congressional Record’, accessed 2 November 2024. Page 6248.
[97] US Congress (1996) ‘Public Law 104-208’, accessed 4 November 2024.
[98] CDC (2024) ‘About Firearm Injury and Death’, accessed 4 November 2024.
[99] Ibid. Page 6253.
[100] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Political Cowardice Stems From Myth Of Unsworth Defeat’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[101] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘For The Survivors, The Suffering Continues’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[102] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Political Cowardice Stems From Myth Of Unsworth Defeat’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[103] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Mass Murderers ‘usually Bad Rather Than Mad’’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[104] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Horrifying side-effect of me generation’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[105] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Scotland killings may have been the catalyst’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[106] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Politicians targeted’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[107] Ibid.
[108] Ibid.
[109] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Lobbyists for tighter laws foresaw horror’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[110] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Politicians targeted’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[111] Ibid.
[112] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Atrocity sparks gun law plea’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[113] The Australian Financial Review (1996) ‘Gun Owners Should Bear the Cost’, accessed 16th November 2024.
[114] Ibid.
[115] The Australian Financial Review (1996) ‘National Gun Laws – Now’, accessed 16th November 2024.
[116] The Australian Financial Review (1996) ‘Deadly Rhetoric of Shooters’, accessed 16th November 2024.
[117] The Australian Financial Review (1996) ‘Howard Urges Buyback Plan for Weapons’, accessed 16th November 2024.
[118] Hansard HR Deb. Page 25, 30 April 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 1 November 2024].
[119] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘The Prime Minister’s Statement of Gun Control House of Representatives’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[120] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘Transcript of the Prime Minister the Hon John Howard MP Gun Rally Sale, Victoria’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[121] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘The Prime Minister’s Statement of Gun Control House of Representatives’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[122] Hansard HR Deb. Page 24, 30 April 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 1 November 2024].
[123] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘Transcript of the Prime Minister the Hon John Howard MP Gun Rally Sale, Victoria’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[124] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘The Prime Minister’s Statement of Gun Control House of Representatives’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[125] Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (1996) ‘Transcript of the Prime Minister the Hon John Howard MP Gun Rally Sale, Victoria’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[126] Ibid.
[127] Hansard HR Deb. Page 24, 30 April 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 1 November 2024].
[128] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Atrocity sparks gun law plea’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[129] The University of Sydney (2021) ‘Port Arthur and the battle for tougher gun laws’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[130] Chapman, Simon (1998) ‘OVER OUR DEAD BODIES Port Arthur and Australia’s fight for gun control’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[131] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘Political Cowardice Stems From Myth Of Unsworth Defeat’, accessed 28 October 2024.
[132] The Sydney Morning Herald (1996) ‘In The Firing Line – Tighter Laws On Guns’, accessed 1 November 2024.
[133] Chapman, Simon (1998) ‘OVER OUR DEAD BODIES Port Arthur and Australia’s fight for gun control’, accessed 1 November 2024. Page 108.
[134] Hansard HR Deb. Page 24, 30 April 1996. [Online]. [Accessed 1 November 2024].
Did you find this story interesting? Please support AOAV's work and donate.
Donate