Categories

The British Military-Industrial complex scrutinisedAOAV: all our reportsArms exports examined

A narrow conversation: why does the UK government’s economic security debate exclude voices that matter?

On 8 May 2025, the UK Parliament’s Business and Trade Subcommittee on Economic Security, Arms and Export Controls convened a session on “UK economic security”. And what it most revealed, through its choice of witnesses, was just how narrowly that concept is defined.

Called to give oral evidence were the great and the “good”: Helen Kennett from Global Counsel, Alexandra Kellert of Control Risks, Sir Simon Fraser of Flint Global, Catherine Royle from NATO’s Joint Force Command Brunssum, The Lord Sedwill, Dr Francesca Ghiretti from RAND Europe, Mike Reid from Frog Capital, and corporate lawyers Nicole Kar (Paul, Weiss) and Martin McElwee (Freshfields).

Together, they represent a cross-section not of British society, but of a tightly knit world of defence consultancy, investment capital, high-level diplomacy, and corporate law.

These are people who understand power because they work close to it. But this proximity also limits the discussion. Their version of “economic security” tends to revolve around managing risk for business, protecting the strategic advantages of the UK’s defence-industrial base, and identifying external threats to market stability. They don’t ask any critical questions, per se, of the military-industrial complex itself.

Accordingly, what was missing was any meaningful consideration of social security, democratic accountability, or the ethical dimensions of Britain’s global economic footprint.

There were no representatives from trade unions. No civil society organisations. No human rights groups. No investigative reporters.

No voices from the global South whose populations often bear the brunt of British arms exports.

No critical academics or policy researchers focused on disarmament, accountability, or environmental harm.

The absence of such voices matters. Not just because it limits the range of evidence, but because it reveals what Parliament currently considers to be legitimate expertise on questions of national security.

The inclusion of figures like Lord Sedwill or advisors from RAND and NATO reinforces the dominant worldview: one where economic security is seen as a question of resilience against foreign powers, not of justice or equality at home and abroad. Yet this is a dangerously incomplete framing. British economic policy has global consequences.

When UK-manufactured weapons are used in Gaza or Yemen, or when surveillance software ends up in the hands of authoritarian regimes, or when economic leverage is used to secure energy deals in unstable regions, these are not just foreign policy issues – they are questions of moral and democratic concern.

By failing to engage with these dimensions, the 8 May session reproduced a narrow and elite-focused understanding of security. It was an exercise in insulation rather than interrogation. And it missed a crucial opportunity to ask what, and whom, our current economic policies really serve.

A broader conversation is urgently needed – one that includes the silenced and the impacted, not just the well-positioned and the well-connected.

Next time, perhaps they might consider inviting Action on Armed Violence to give evidence. We wait with high hopes.