A few years ago I interviewed a battle-hardened Israeli veteran who refused to go on the record. One line has stayed with me. “Iain,” he said, “you must remember that a Jewish mother’s loss of a son is 50 times worse than an Arab mother’s loss of a son.”
It was a hard sentence to hear. I faltered in reporting it then: it was too emotive, too toxic. Grief cannot be measured against grief.
Yet the phrase echoes back at me now for it rests uncannily close to the logic voiced in a recent leaked recording by Maj. Gen. (res.) Aharon Haliva, Israel’s former head of military intelligence.
Wars are often narrated through abstractions. Sometimes it is deterrence, sometimes sovereignty, often national security. But in the end they are measured in bodies.
And the Gaza war, soon entering its third year, has been stripped down to the cruel logic of arithmetic.
In the leaked recording broadcast by Channel 12 on 15 August 2025, Haliva justified Gaza’s staggering death toll with startling candour.
“For everything that happened on October 7, for every person on October 7, 50 Palestinians should die,” he said. “There’s no choice, they need a Nakba every now and then to feel the consequences. I’m not saying this out of revenge, but as a message for future generations.”
This was not the voice of an outsider. Haliva led the directorate that failed to foresee Hamas’s assault, despite intelligence warnings the night before of unusual activity along the border. On 7 October 2023, while on holiday in Eilat, he dismissed a late-night call and went back to sleep. By dawn Hamas had stormed through the fence, killing some 1,150 Israeli civilians and abducting more than 200. Haliva resigned six months later, the first senior official to do so.
Now his leaked words reveal the possible mindset behind Israel’s chosen path of retribution.
His formula is brutal: one Israeli death demands fifty Palestinian ones. By his reckoning, 50,000 Palestinians should already have been killed. According to modelling by The Lancet, the toll now approaches 90,000, with two-thirds civilians. This is not deterrence, nor legal self-defence. It is punishment pitched as generational warning. It is a deliberate reprise of the 1948 Nakba, when over 700,000 Palestinians were driven from their homes. Where Israeli leaders usually insist civilian deaths are collateral, Haliva made them the point.
Death is the message.
The numbers are obscene. If 1,150 Israelis died on 7 October, Haliva’s ratio demanded 57,500 Palestinians. The actual toll already surpasses that: roughly sixty Palestinians for each Israeli. Hospitals, schools, and refugee camps lie in ruins. By April 2024, the UN had recorded more than 13,000 Palestinian children killed. UNICEF declared Gaza “the most dangerous place in the world to be a child.” The WHO has verified over 800 attacks on health facilities.
Israel insists it takes extraordinary precautions: dropping leaflets, making warning calls, firing “roof-knock” munitions. The figures belie it. Israeli officials say Hamas bears ultimate blame for embedding in civilian areas.
And the calculus of cruelty in the numbers of the dead has infected the wider debate. Yahya Sinwar, Hamas’s now-deceased leader in Gaza, reportedly said 100,000 Palestinian deaths would be a price worth paying for Gaza’s freedom. And Motaz Azaiza, the Gazan photojournalist, once claimed that “a single Palestinian is worth more than a thousand Israelis.”
Such grotesque rhetoric does not absolve Israel. A democracy cannot mirror a death cult. The Geneva Conventions demand civilian harm be proportionate to military advantage. Haliva’s words puncture that claim. To declare that tens of thousands must die “as a message” is to admit intent.
Israel had other options. It could have persisted with its policy of containment: periodic bombardments, deadly but limited. In 2014, around 2,200 Palestinians and 73 Israelis died; Hamas took years to recover. After the 2021 conflict, recovery was similarly slow. One projection suggested that two decades of such cycles might have killed some 26,000 Palestinians, including 15,800 civilians. This is appalling, but far below the 90,000 plausibly dead in less than two years.
The current strategy multiplies the carnage severalfold.
Haliva’s confession matters because it undermines Israel’s narrative abroad. Washington has demanded “credible explanations” for Gaza’s civilian toll. London has sought assurances its arms exports are not complicit. The International Court of Justice is already considering South Africa’s genocide case against Israel. Genocide is defined not by numbers alone but by intent. To say Palestinians “need a Nakba every now and then” and that “for every Israeli killed, 50 Palestinians should die” is precisely the sort of evidence prosecutors seize upon. This is not collateral damage. It is declared policy.
Haliva’s words should be remembered for their candour. They strip away euphemism and reveal the truth: Gaza’s civilians are not dying by accident but by design, their lives valued at one-fiftieth of an Israeli’s. The world must decide how many more zeros it is willing to tolerate.
At some point, perhaps a point long since passed, all arithmetic becomes atrocity.
Did you find this story interesting? Please support AOAV's work and donate.
Donate