An investigation published by Australia’s The Saturday Paper has revealed that Australia has yet to approve a single compensation payment under a scheme established to provide redress to Afghan victims of alleged war crimes committed by its special forces.
Australia’s 2020 Brereton inquiry identified credible information concerning the alleged unlawful killing of 39 Afghans across 23 incidents. It recommended compensation without requiring a criminal conviction.
Yet, almost two years after a compensation scheme was established, none of the claims had resulted in an approved payment.
Of 105 submissions recorded by June 2026, 45 had been deemed ineligible.
Among those rejected was Ghulam Jailani, who says Australian soldiers shot him during a 2006 raid in Uruzgan, leaving him blind in one eye and with bullets still lodged in his chest. His claim was refused not because his account was a lie, but because the incident fell outside the findings covered by the Brereton report.
This exposes a fundamental injustice: victims may be denied compensation because their suffering was never adequately investigated in the first place.
The implications for Britain’s Independent Inquiry relating to Afghanistan, chaired by Lord Justice Charles Haddon-Cave, cannot be ignored.
That inquiry is examining allegations that British special forces unlawfully killed Afghan civilians and detainees between 2010 and 2013, alongside allegations of institutional cover-ups and failures by the Royal Military Police.
As AOAV has previously reported, an expert review found that Operation Northmoor, the principal military police investigation, suffered from serious delays, inadequate resources and failures of oversight. The British inquiry must now avoid a second injustice: allowing a process designed to establish accountability to become detached from the people whose deaths and injuries prompted it.
There are several lessons Lord Justice Charles Haddon-Cave and his team should heed.
First, Afghan families are central to proceedings. Their testimony deserves proper consideration, accessible interpretation and independent legal support. They must be treated as participants in the search for truth, not merely witnesses to British institutional failures.
Second, allegations falling outside the inquiry’s formal scope must not be simply ignored. Where credible evidence emerges of other unlawful killings or serious injuries, there must be a mechanism for independent investigation.
Third, compensation and other forms of redress should not depend solely upon successful criminal prosecutions. Where credible evidence establishes wrongful harm, the government should provide a meaningful route to redress. This might include compensation, acknowledgement and appropriate assistance to surviving families.
Finally, families deserve explanations of what happened, why investigations failed and what the British state intends to do about it.
The inquiry itself cannot determine criminal or civil liability, nor is it a compensation tribunal. But its findings and recommendations can help establish the basis for a separate, credible reparations process.
The rights of British special forces personnel remain important. Allegations must be rigorously tested, evidence fairly assessed and the presumption of innocence respected. These are essential requirements of justice. But justice cannot be measured solely by whether British soldiers are prosecuted or cleared.
It must also be measured by whether Afghan families finally discover the truth, receive acknowledgement of their suffering and obtain meaningful redress.
Australia’s experience suggests that even an inquiry which exposes grave wrongdoing can leave victims abandoned by the state.
Britain must not repeat that.
Did you find this story interesting? Please support AOAV's work and donate.
Donate