Categories

Explosive violence by the Israeli Defense ForcesAOAV: all our reportsExplosive violence in GazaImpact of explosive violence on civilians

The casualty ratios that complicate Israeli claims about Gaza

A statistic cited as evidence of military precision tells a more complicated story. As those who follow the harm of war know well, casualty numbers, in wartime, quickly become weapons of their own. 

Israel’s defenders have lately seized on one in particular: that among Gazans aged 15–39 killed since October 7th 2023, roughly 3.2 men have died for every woman. Since fighters are overwhelmingly male – their argument sounds – such a skew suggests that Israel was hitting combatants, not civilians. 

The logic sounds reasonable. But the comparative data tell a different story.

Our review of 21 conflicts and episodes of mass violence for which age- and sex-disaggregated casualty figures exist places Gaza’s ratio at the low end of the range. The median across those cases is 8.49 men per woman. Gaza’s figure falls below 17 of the 21.

The conflicts nearest to Gaza on this measure make for awkward company. The Hamas-led attacks in Israel on October 7th produced a ratio of roughly 2.74 among victims aged 15–39. Casualty data from inside Israel in the years before that attack yield 3.45. Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge shows 4.17. 

Now this is important, because all sit in much the same demographic area. Only two well-documented cases fall significantly lower. One is the Rwandan genocide of 1994, where the slaughter of entire communities produced a ratio of 1.07. The other is the El Mozote massacre in El Salvador in 1981, when government troops killed nearly an entire village, yielding 0.65. 

In both, the distribution of victims approached that of the civilian population itself, because violence was largely indiscriminate.

A signature in the data
Where military forces primarily kill combatants, the demographic pattern looks very different. In Bosnia (1992–95) the ratio reaches 25.5. Croatia’s war of independence shows 24.4. Ireland’s revolutionary period (1916–21) produces 19.2. The early phase of the Iraq war (2003–04) yields roughly 9.5. 

This is important because these conflicts exhibit ratios between three and eight times higher than Gaza’s recent toll.

The arithmetic is relatively straightforward. Armies that concentrate lethal force on fighters generate casualty tolls that are heavily weighted toward military-age men.  Of course, civilian deaths still occur, and often in tragic numbers.  But the demographic signature remains strongly male.

Some cases illustrate the opposite danger. Extremely high male-to-female ratios can themselves signal atrocity. In the West Bank, ratios estimated from available records exceed 40 before October 7th and surpass 70 afterwards. Such levels are outdone only by horrors like the Srebrenica massacre of 1995, when Bosnian Serb forces executed more than 8,000 Bosniak men and boys; a horror that produced a ratio above 180. 

And at those extremes, the pattern reflects the deliberate targeting of men, not the selective killing of combatants.

Of course, none of these statistics settles the legal or moral arguments over the war in Gaza. Casualty ratios cannot determine who was a fighter, who was a civilian, or whether a given strike was lawful. They are, necessarily and inherently, a blunt instrument. And yet what they do reveal is something about how violence is distributed across a population.

On that measure, Gaza looks unusual.  As it stands, the ratio of 3.2 sits far closer to cases in which violence swept broadly through civilian communities than it does to conflicts in which fighters made up most of the dead.  So, the statistic so often cited as proof of precision does not obviously support that claim. 

If anything, it suggests that deaths in Gaza are spread widely across the population rather than concentrated among combatants.