Categories

Militarism examinedUK Special Forces killings in Afghanistan investigatedUK Special ForcesAOAV: all our reports

UK Special Forces chief N2252 says concerns over rising Afghan killings prompted internal tactics review

A former senior Special Forces officer has told the Afghanistan Inquiry that concerns about rising numbers of Afghan deaths during UK Special Forces raids prompted an internal review of tactics in 2011, after commanders began noticing a pattern of operations in which more people were killed than weapons recovered.

In a witness statement, the former Chief of Staff of the Director of Special Forces headquarters said he became aware in early 2011 of an increase in fatalities during detention operations in Afghanistan. He stressed that this was not, in itself, evidence of wrongdoing and could have been explained by a more aggressive operational tempo, improved intelligence and air support, better weather conditions and pressure on Special Forces to suppress Taliban networks.

Nevertheless, the former officer said the trend was “not irrelevant” and warranted scrutiny. He also recalled concerns among operations staff that a compound-clearance tactic was inadvertently allowing detainees to re-enter buildings, arm themselves and then be shot after posing what troops regarded as an immediate threat.

The officer said he raised both issues directly with the Director of Special Forces in what he described as an unusually serious private discussion where he “closed the door”.

He urged the commander to seek further advice and ensure the issues were properly examined. He later became aware of allegations circulating within Special Forces circles in April 2011 concerning the use of lethal force by troops in Afghanistan. According to his contemporaneous diary notes, the allegations were regarded as second-hand rumours rather than evidence of criminal conduct. The notes record discussions about whether there was sufficient information to justify a Royal Military Police investigation, concluding instead that an internal review of tactics, techniques and procedures would be more effective.

The witness said he was never aware of evidence that Special Forces personnel had planted weapons, falsified records or carried out extra-judicial killings. However, he acknowledged concerns over incidents based on email chains where there appeared to be “more bodies than weapons”, a phrase used internally when the number of people killed exceeded the number of weapons recovered from a target.

He said such cases required closer examination because they raised questions about the circumstances of the shootings, although they did not necessarily indicate unlawful conduct.

The statement also sheds new light on internal unease over how some operations were being documented. Referring to legal advice provided at the time, the witness said there were concerns that certain accounts of shootings, including repeated references to insurgents retrieving grenades from behind curtains, might not withstand scrutiny in future public inquiries. He said the review ordered in April 2011 focused on whether existing tactics struck the right balance between detaining suspects and minimising risks to troops and civilians.

The witness said the review ultimately led to changes in operational procedures, including greater involvement of Afghan partner forces during compound clearances. He recalled that, once the review had been completed, concerns about the tactic largely disappeared from discussion within headquarters.